Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    TRENDING :
    • The Jensen Huang spy scandal is becoming a White House problem
    • Sean Tucker Stuck on Special Teams Again in Week 9
    • Fake News – Are They Stupid Or On The Take?
    • Forget the office potluck. A new holiday food tradition is catching on at work
    • Boise State Soccer Stuns Washington State for First Pac-12 Title Shot
    • AIPAC Spent $84 Million Influencing American Midterm Elections
    • Her soda disrupter brand sold for $2B. Now she’s coming for hydration
    • CJ Beach Dies at 22: What We Know
    Populist Bulletin
    • Home
    • US Politics
    • World Politics
    • Economy
    • Business
    • Headline News
    Populist Bulletin
    Home»Business»The value of the AI is not its ability to create product for us, but to engage with us in our process
    Business 5 Mins Read

    The value of the AI is not its ability to create product for us, but to engage with us in our process

    Business 5 Mins Read
    Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email Copy Link
    Follow Us
    Google News Flipboard
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    The most common email messages I receive these days are obviously AI-generated pitches for guests to appear on my podcast. They all begin the same way, with a praising reference to one of my recent episodes—usually the second-to-last posted show. “Your recent interview with so-and-so was penetrating, and got to the heart of the problem of x or y.” Then comes the crucial pivot: “John Dough’s work takes that problem even further . . .” And then the pitch for John Dough to be on the podcast. 

    The problem is not just that the publicist used AI to shotgun the known universe of podcasters with pitches artificially customized to their shows. It’s that the comparisons and connections are really bad. “Your guest spoke so passionately about being a death doula, I think you would be so interested in an artist who makes Halloween napkins festooned with skeletons, which are usually of dead people.” 

    So what do I do? I blacklist the sender. The human publicist ends up losing credibility because the one thing I might trust her to do—to accurately assess the appropriateness of my show for her guest—had been surrendered to a machine whose job was to make that connection by any means necessary. 

    {“blockType”:”mv-promo-block”,”data”:{“imageDesktopUrl”:”https://images.fastcompany.com/image/upload/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit/wp-cms-2/2025/10/adus-labs-16×9-1.png”,”imageMobileUrl”:”https://images.fastcompany.com/image/upload/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit/wp-cms-2/2025/10/anduslabs.png”,”eyebrow”:””,”headline”:”Get more insights from Douglas Rushkoff and Andus Labs.”,”dek”:”Keep up to date on the latest trends on how AI is reshaping culture and business, through the critical lens of human agency.”,”ctaText”:”Learn More”,”ctaUrl”:”https://www.anduslabs.com/perspectives”,”theme”:{“bg”:”#1a064b”,”text”:”#ffffff”,”eyebrow”:”#9aa2aa”,”buttonBg”:”#ffffff”,”buttonText”:”#000000″},”imageDesktopId”:91420531,”imageMobileId”:91420530}}

    She was using AI in the fashion of an Industrial Age factory owner to increase her productivity, but simultaneously ignoring the human process that defines her expertise.

    I see the same thing happen with AI-generated reports and presentations. Someone gets some speculative idea and then asks Chat to justify it with a few case studies. On the surface, the case studies may sound like they’re supporting the premise—but if you look any deeper, they don’t really relate at all. They’re analogous, but not truly relevant. Worse yet, they’re sitting in what looks like a fully realized Powerpoint presentation. Concepts that could have been interpreted as half-baked, speculative, or open to discussion now appear finalized. They seem inappropriately unrealized for how elaborately they have been rendered, and make the presenter seem foolish. (That is, if the recipient is even reading the work rather than having their AI summarize it.)

    Deskilling ourselves

    By using the AI to do the big stuff—by outsourcing our primary competencies to the machines instead of giving them the boring busywork—we deskill ourselves and deprive everyone of the opportunity for AI-enhanced outputs. Too many of us are using AI as the primary architect for a project, rather than the general contractor who supports the architect’s human vision. (And even many of the general contractor’s functions are attributable to the human relationships they have developed over the years.) 

    People are treating their chats as if they were fully realized (but as yet nonexistent) AGIs, and letting them do big stuff rather than treating them like tools that can do lots of little stuff. When facing a new seemingly gargantuan project, they turn to the AI first rather than digging in and doing some research—perhaps even using the AI as a research tool instead of relegating the whole project to it all at once. The output looks good to the user, less because it is good than because the Chat has been programmed to make the user feel good about their query. “That’s an insightful project idea, Douglas! I’ve managed to flesh out an entire proposal at three different price points.” The positive feedback loop reinforces the user behavior, until the threshold for asking the Chat to do the project is lower and lower. In the name of getting more product out there, the user loses touch with their own process—their core competency. 

    No shortcuts

    The only ones who win in such a scenario are the AI companies, who effectively commoditize the users and their companies. Without any core competencies, the only competitive advantage a user has left is the robustness of their service contract with the AI company. The fast, slapdash results are not worth the cost in human expertise. 

    As the researcher behind MIT’s study “This is Your Brain on ChatGPT” explained at a recent ANDUS event, when people turn to an AI for a solution before working on a problem themselves, the number of connections formed in their brains decreases. But when they turn to the AI after working on the problem for a while, they end up with more neural connections than if they worked entirely alone. 

    That’s because the value of the AI is not its ability to create product for us, but to engage with us in our process. Working and iterating with an AI—doing what we could call generative thinking—is actually a break from Industrial Age thinking. We focus less on outputs than on cycles. Less on the volume of short-term results (assembly line), and more on the quality and complexity of thought and innovation. 

    AI’s don’t have to replace our competencies or even our employees. That’s less an opportunity for success and scale than it is a recipe for deskilling, commodification, and eventual disappearance. 

    Adopting AI as a partner in process and enhancer of competencies requires developing a new kind of culture around technology and innovation—one that centers the human ingenuity at the core of a company, and supports the ways that new, intelligent technologies can foster that living resource. 

    {“blockType”:”mv-promo-block”,”data”:{“imageDesktopUrl”:”https://images.fastcompany.com/image/upload/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit/wp-cms-2/2025/10/adus-labs-16×9-1.png”,”imageMobileUrl”:”https://images.fastcompany.com/image/upload/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit/wp-cms-2/2025/10/anduslabs.png”,”eyebrow”:””,”headline”:”Get more insights from Douglas Rushkoff and Andus Labs.”,”dek”:”Keep up to date on the latest trends on how AI is reshaping culture and business, through the critical lens of human agency.”,”ctaText”:”Learn More”,”ctaUrl”:”https://www.anduslabs.com/perspectives”,”theme”:{“bg”:”#1a064b”,”text”:”#ffffff”,”eyebrow”:”#9aa2aa”,”buttonBg”:”#ffffff”,”buttonText”:”#000000″},”imageDesktopId”:91420531,”imageMobileId”:91420530}}



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    The Jensen Huang spy scandal is becoming a White House problem

    November 10, 2026

    Forget the office potluck. A new holiday food tradition is catching on at work

    November 10, 2026

    Her soda disrupter brand sold for $2B. Now she’s coming for hydration

    November 10, 2026
    Top News
    Business 3 Mins Read

    New Episode of Kyle Van Noy’s ‘Elite Eatz’: An NFL Comeback

    Business 3 Mins Read

    Key Takeaways NFL great Kyle Van Noy’s show “Elite Eatz” features conversations with amazing athletes…

    Infant botulism outbreak: Baby formula sold at Target recalled as potentially deadly infection spreads to 3 states

    June 16, 2026

    OpenAI’s Sora used to make deepfake AI videos of dead celebrities, outraging their families

    October 11, 2025

    US May Keep Iran Naval Blockade Indefinitely

    August 15, 2026
    Top Trending
    Business 7 Mins Read

    The Jensen Huang spy scandal is becoming a White House problem

    Business 7 Mins Read

    The scandal engulfing Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang is no longer simply a…

    World Politics 1 Min Read

    Sean Tucker Stuck on Special Teams Again in Week 9

    World Politics 1 Min Read

    Buccaneers running back Sean Tucker is once again being used primarily on…

    Economy 2 Mins Read

    Fake News – Are They Stupid Or On The Take?

    Economy 2 Mins Read

    I watched the 60 minute interview of Trump and there too they…

    Categories
    • Business
    • Economy
    • Headline News
    • Top News
    • US Politics
    • World Politics
    About us

    The Populist Bulletin was founded with a fervent commitment to inform, inspire, empower and spark meaningful conversations about the economy, business, politics, government accountability, globalization, and the preservation of American cultural heritage.

    We are devoted to delivering straightforward, unfiltered, compelling, relatable stories that resonate with the majority of the American public, while boldly challenging false mainstream narratives that seem to only serve entrenched elitists, and foreign interests.

    Top Picks

    The Jensen Huang spy scandal is becoming a White House problem

    November 10, 2026

    Sean Tucker Stuck on Special Teams Again in Week 9

    November 10, 2026

    Fake News – Are They Stupid Or On The Take?

    November 10, 2026
    Categories
    • Business
    • Economy
    • Headline News
    • Top News
    • US Politics
    • World Politics
    Copyright © 2025 Populist Bulletin. All Rights Reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.