It’s the latest move in the administration’s all-out effort to deny government benefits to immigrants—even those living and working here legally.
The Trump administration recently proposed a change to tax credits that would, if finalized, significantly impoverish hundreds of thousands of legal immigrants—as well as their US citizen children. It’s the latest move in the administration’s all-out effort to deny government benefits to immigrants—both those who are undocumented and those legally living and working in the United States—in order to make life in the county as miserable as possible for them.
The proposed rule, released by the Treasury Department in August, targets four federal tax credits—the Earned Income Tax Credit, the Child Tax Credit, the American Opportunity Tax Credit, and the Adoption Credit—that give tax refunds to filers who earn below a certain threshold. The EITC and CTC are by far the largest and most commonly claimed. Over 1 million people live in families that could lose access to the CTC and 602,000 could lose access to the EITC. About 515,000 could lose both.
The immigrants who will be affected by the rule change include the recipients of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals—people who have been living in the United States since they were very young and don’t know any other place to call home—those who have pending asylum applications with work authorization, those with Temporary Protected Status, those with visas for victims of violence and crimes, those with employment and student visas, those granted parole for less than a year, and children who have been abused or neglected by their parents. The average family losing the credits because they are DACA recipients would forgo $4,560 in tax credits per year, amounting to 13 percent of their income. “That is not a drop in the bucket for those families,” Davis said. “They are going to feel that.”
The EITC and CTC have long required a work-authorized Social Security number, which can only be obtained with some sort of legal status. “This is not a credit where a migrant can cross the border and start receiving it in the next day,” pointed out Carl Davis, research director at the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy. But while an immigrant with one of the targeted statuses who is married to a citizen will be protected, single parents or people who are married to someone else with one of these statuses will not. Meanwhile, about 523,000 children live in families that could lose the CTC and 279,000 are in families that could lose the EITC. About 90 percent of those children are US citizens. “When a family loses access to a credit like this, it affects everyone on the return,” Davis pointed out. “The kids are going to suffer too.”
The EITC and CTC help working families avoid poverty by giving them income support. Families often use the money to fill gaps in their budgets, buying necessities like food and diapers, repairing cars, paying off owed rent, or paying for their children’s extracurriculars. “They can use the money in the way that’s most effective and most important for their families,” said Kris Cox, director of federal tax policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. These measures have proven effective. Refundable tax credits kept over 10 million people out of poverty in 2025. When the CTC was expanded in 2021, child poverty fell to the lowest level recorded.
The families targeted by the rule change pay taxes to the federal government through Social Security taxes, income taxes, sales taxes, and property taxes, meaning they are still “paying on net to the federal government,” noted Ben D’Avanzo, senior strategist for federal advocacy at the National Immigration Law Center. If the rule were finalized, they would stop getting a benefit they help to fund. It would create “a two-tiered tax system,” D’Avanzo explained, “where immigrants essentially pay higher taxes than other people, without getting the benefits in return.”
The rule could also scare immigrants away from paying taxes after years of the IRS trying to encourage them to file. For the first time, filers will have to correctly report their immigration status on their returns, and the IRS will have to verify it, even though it currently has no system for doing so. In a draft tax form for 2026, the IRS has added a box asking, “At the time you file your return, are you, and your spouse if filing jointly, a U.S. citizen, U.S. national, or an alien lawfully authorized to work in the U.S.? (see instructions).” That question has “never been on there before,” Cox said. It has also drafted a new form for claiming the refundable tax credits that askes, “Are you or your spouse a U.S. citizen, U.S national, or qualified alien?”
Such questions could deter immigrants from filing their taxes, particularly after the IRS shared information on tens of thousands of people with Immigration and Customs Enforcement in 2025 (a practice courts have since blocked). “There will be some people who are just frightened about answering any questions related to their immigration status and might feel chilled answering these questions,” said Shelby Gonzales, vice president for immigration policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, even though failing to file could result in criminal penalties. Many immigrants may not know if their particular status is “qualified” for the credits or not; some might need the help of an immigration lawyer to figure it out. “If I am an immigrant, I do not have a card that says, ‘You have a qualifying immigration status,’” Gonzales pointed out. “People are not going to risk this if they don’t know for sure that they fit into one of those categories.”
“It’s unavoidable that people who are eligible for the credits, who remain eligible despite this rule” will end up without them “because of this confusion and fear,” Cox added.
The proposed rule is an outgrowth of changes made in sweeping welfare reform legislation passed in 1996, which for the first time denied this group of lawful immigrants cash welfare. They were “vilified for a conservative agenda,” said D’Avanzo, as “people who do not deserve help, do not deserve the ability to have access to support for their families.” But for the last 30 years, Congress has never applied that restriction to other benefits and programs. “This rule is really upending 30 years of precedent and policy,” Cox said.
If the rule is finalized, it’s likely to face a challenge in court. Congress “clearly thought about this issue and has crafted its own restrictions [for these tax credits], and now the administration wants to go farther,” Davis said. In 1996 Congress also passed legislation restricting the EITC to people with Social Security numbers—which these immigrants have—and there is language in current statute that says noncitizens are eligible for tax credits. “The administration is attempting to usurp Congress’s authority in setting tax law and creating its own rules,” D’Avanzo asserted, “driven not by what the law itself says but by their really deranged anti-immigrant sentiments.”
The administration also had a chance to create these changes legislatively, but it didn’t: Trump’s huge tax-focused reconciliation bill, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which passed last year with only Republican votes, didn’t include anything limiting tax credits for legal immigrants. At the same time, Republicans did take away some benefits—Medicaid and CHIP funding, Affordable Care Act exchange premium tax credits, Medicare, and food stamps—from a similar group of immigrants, leaving them only available to citizens, green-card holders, and a few others.
Popular
“swipe left below to view more authors”Swipe →
The Trump administration has already tried to apply the immigration-related restrictions of the 1996 welfare reform law to other programs, most notably Head Start. Last year, a handful of federal agencies issued guidance saying they would classify the same group of immigrants as ineligible for Head Start enrollment, as well as for access to things like mental health services, domestic violence shelters, adult education programs, and federally funded health centers, deeming these things to also be “public benefits.” The effort has been permanently blocked by the courts nationwide, in part because the judge said the agencies violated procedure in issuing the guidance. But the judge left open the possibility of agencies’ issuing rules similar to what the IRS has proposed for tax credits in an attempt to do it in a more lawful way. “It would not be surprising,” D’Avanzo said, if the agencies try again through rulemaking.
In November, the administration did the same thing to a variety of programs at the Department of Housing and Urban Development, many of which fund affordable housing and homelessness services. The administration has also finalized a rule that prohibits entire families with mixed immigration status—where one or more family members don’t have a qualifying immigration status, even if others do—from living in federally subsidized housing, including both public housing and private apartments that receive rental assistance. Nearly 80,000 people could lose their rental assistance, including 52,500 citizens.
The administration has also finalized a harsh so-called “public charge” rule that will allow immigration officials to deny people’s green-card applications. It gives these officials wide latitude to take an immigrant’s use of nearly any public benefit into account and deem that it’s a negative factor in their quest for legal status. Most of the immigrants who go through that process are not undocumented and have a pathway toward lawful permanent status, but now they will face the choice between keeping benefits that allow them and their families to eat and survive or giving them up for a shot at a green card. Between 1.4 million and 4.1 million people could end up deciding to disenroll from Medicaid and CHIP, including their 1.7 million children who are US citizens. When the Trump administration issued a similar rule during his first term, which was later blocked by the courts, it still led 31 percent of adults in families with at least one family member who did not yet have a green card to forgo benefits. It’s “another way of scaring people who remain eligible for benefit programs from accessing them,” Gonzales said.
On top of all of that, early in Trump’s second administration he rescinded a Biden-era rule that allowed DACA recipients to get health coverage on the Affordable Care Act exchanges, instead blocking them from that option.
This is “a very coordinated effort to take away eligibility for benefit programs,” Gonzales noted. And that is meant to make life as uncomfortable as possible for immigrants in this country, with and without legal status. The Trump administration is using “every lever of the federal government for making immigrants feel unwelcome and unsafe living in the United States,” D’Avanzo said. “The overarching goal is to make it as hard as possible to be an immigrant in the United States.”
More from The Nation

A conversation with Sara Bennett as well as two of the women she photographed for her new book, Looking Inside: Women with Life Sentences.

It is now over seven months since my son, my husband, and I were detained. It feels like being stabbed in the heart again and again.

Officials in some states continue to seek the death penalty while others, like Newsom, have vowed to bring the sentences to a halt.



